Hotel Seramar Comodoro Playa

Calle Cala Blanca 9, 07181 Palmanova, Calvia, Majorca Spain
4 star hotel

Overview

Ratings summary

Brilliant
188
Good
239
Average
123
Poor
40
Awful
17

Rating by feature

  • 3.5 room
  • 3.5 pool
  • 5 beach
  • 4.5 service
  • 4.5 dining
  • 3.5 amenities
  • 4.5 food
 

35 Traveller reviews from Holiday Watchdog

My Hen Weekend

3
Average
by

"Arrived at the hotel at 9.30pm, walked into a really nice foyer and a very helpful receptionist. we were all inclusive, but had missed dinner, and they offered us a cold buffet, but we had eaten on the plane and were more interested in the All Inc. bar....

Unpacked in our rooms, which were typical holiday, tiled floor, ensuite bathroom, with lots of towels, hairdryer etc. very impressed, large bed (well two singles, but it was great),

stepped out onto the balcony and it was amazing, the views across the bay are by far one of the best you will experience, especially if you are on a top floor.

2 lifts service the hotel, and beware, they close quicklky and i nearly lost my arm!!

Headed to the bar, the barstaff were a little grumpy, but the holiday rep based at the hotel was ace, a gorgeous little (we think from birmingham) babe, she was ace, and i felt for her a little as the hotel didn't have much for entertainment, we played bingo and a quiz and it was a good laugh for everyone there.

The food was as you would expect from AI, but it was presented well, and i enjoyed most of it.

the pool was small and in the shade most of the morning, getting the sun around 1pm ish. If there is no space at the pool the beach is a 2 minute walk, well, its about 10 seconds, but once you get onto the sand and try find a lounger that takes a bit longer.

Overall very impressed with the hotel,. Great location for the Maguluf strip, infact, it was so close we there.

Had a great hen weekend, and a great stay in majorca!

(we were a group of girls ranging from 21 to 45)"

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Mon 31st of July 2006

Comodoro Fantastic Hotel

5
Brilliant
by

"just back from the comodoro hotel staff and the service we received was excellent so much that we intend to go back later this year"

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Sun 28th of May 2006

i loved it!

4
Good
by

"I was taken to this hotel for my 21st brithday by my parents, an i thought it was great! The staff when we arrived were very friendly an we had to wait no more than an half hour for our room considering that we arrive at 11.30 in the morning and they were fully booked so some guests had not left yet. The room was spacious an the view was amazing, you could see all round the bay. It was mostly older people who stayed there and no one of my own age with exception of the bar men. Both the men an women on reception were very friendly and were willing to help with any problems or queries. The dining room staff were quick to clear away tables and there was a wide variety of food, which was at an exceptional level. While we were there we had a groups of men and women on stag and hen parites, the hotel staff did there best to keep big groups on the same floor and single rooms such as families or older couples on the same floor. The entertainment was limited with Bingo, a Quiz and a spanish singer, but the bar men danny and jonathan more than made up for it. Even thought the bar closed at 11pm most guests werent leaving until 1am, the bar staff stayed and entertained the guests, for example on our last nigth one of the bar men asked quests to volunteer and he tried to teach them fancy tricks with the bottles. The staff are always willing to take part in their own entertainment and stick to their word, such as jumping in the swimming pool.
The only problem i had with the hotel was that the pool was freezing as there were no heaters. The outside area was very clean and sweeps were carried out every so often to lift cups and litter.
Overall i enjoyed my stay at the hotel, it was clean, had a good variety of food, the staff were willing to help at any time of the day or night, and it was a minutes walk from the beach. The outstanding points for this hotel would have to be the staff and their friendlyness, i didnt see any discrimination between spanish, english, irish and french. And the stay was so good we are going back again next year."

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Mon 1st of May 2006

what a review

2
Poor
by

"we stayed at the comordoro april 2006.the view when we went on our balcony was to die for.it was the most magnificent view i have ever seen.but that was the only good thing about it.the staff were nice enough.its a four star hotel but in my opinion its only 2 star plus.the all inclusive drinks were the cheapest and nastiness i have ever drank.the food was inedible.there was no entertainment and nothing for children to do."

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Mon 1st of May 2006

not four star

1
Awful
by

"no way is this a four star hotel, the food was appalling, the room was draughty.the inhouse entertainment consisted of bingo and a quiz.there was no dress code in the dining room my wife and i both in our early sixties had to eat out most of the time, the food was so bad poor service at the bar was anotherfault we spent eight days there in late april but we would not go back even at half the price"

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Sun 30th of April 2006

I liked it!

4
Good
by

"We stayed at this hotel over Easter and thoroughly enjoyed our holiday. The staff were friendly and efficient. The rooms were spacious and clean. The balcony was overlooking the sea and the views were wonderful. The food was good and there was plenty of choice. It was nice to sit and eat while watching the sea. The hotel was in a lovely position right by the beach. Our only complaint was the noise at night. We were unlucky and had noisy nieghbours. Once they had disturbed us we noticed all the noise outside. Palma Nova is a lovely resort with plenty going on."

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Tue 25th of April 2006

was fine but not 4 star

4
Good
by

"i stayed at this hotel with my mother and my ten year old son. the food was lovely and very varied and we never struggled for anything to eat although chips at breakfast was a bit much.the entertainment was non existent with bingo or karaoke nearly every night.the hotel was super clean and the staff were very friendly.the all inclusive bar closed promptly at eleven o clock much to the disgust of some other guests although by that time many of them had sampled more than enough of the bars contents.
this holiday was just an extra for me and i was glad this wasnt my full summer holiday also the area arround the hotel was very noisy and i was woken at 3.30 most mornings although i was told it was even worse at peak times. if you go to this hotel make sure you dont get a room on the corner because although they are bigger slightly you do not get the corridor shielding you from some of the noise.
the pool was quite small and very cold because of the trees and surrounding buildings but it is right on the beach but there were lots of sunbeds although i could imagine that it would be a nightmare trying to get one at peak season.
i wouldnt be in a rush to go back to this hotel but neither would i advise anyone not to go.i would not say it justifies its 4 star rating given the opening hours of the bar and the fact that you must go the dining room even if u just want a snack and there is nothing to eat after dinner ends at 9 o clock."

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Tue 25th of October 2005

not a 4 star by any means!!

1
Awful
by

"my parents in there 60's, myself and children 12 and 13 visited this hotel mid aug as all inclusive guests. arriving at 3am the only thing you want is your room which was very spacious.
bar area poor service as very slow and if you are spanish ayou take preference and get served immedialtely otherwise long wait. bar started closing at 10.55pm and under no circumstances could you get a drink at 1 minute past 11!! tables very left for hours without being cleared or wiped so big built up of glasses and ashtrays which were disgusting.
food very selected and repeatative nothing for children or vegetarians and only luke warm again if spanish then nothing too much trouble.
pool very cold even in the peak season and very shaded with large trees so looked nothing like the picture we saw in our brochure. sunbed cushions left out all night so either were wet if it had rained in night or had bird droppings on them. brochure also said theat beach sunbeds and parasols included with hotel this was not the case at all you had to pay 2.5 euro's for each.
entertainment was a joke as there wasn't any daytime activities and either bingo or karaoke in the evening and there was one live act which again was repeated the following week.
location was good as only few feet from the beach and views from rooms were good. no courtesy room available on day of departure and all guests before us and ourselves were told the same, if you want to shower before you travel home then there is a shower outside at the side of the pool!! i kicked up a stink about this and got in touch with the area rep and it was organised for us to have a room to freshen up.
this hotel is not for children nothing for them to do at all and obviously not for vegetarians. will not be visitings it again"

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Thu 13th of October 2005

short trip OK

4
Good
by

"Just back from a 2 night weekend stay at this hotel in Palma Nova. Although the address is said to be Palma Nova, I think it must be the last hotel before the resort becomes Magaluf. It is on the doorstep of the much noiser resort. The hotel itself was first class. We stayed on an all inclusive basis. Can't fault it ! Food was ample and really nice. The bar was clean and had friendly staff. Rooms were lovely. It is ideally situated right on the beach. Only about 10 steps needed to take you right to the sand! Ideal for the walk back and forth to the free bar all day!

Although the hotel is so close to Magaluf, we did not have any young teenagers in our hotel. Most of the guests were well into their 40s and over. This hotel has best of both worlds, VERY near all the nightlife but well kept with high standards throughout. Would recommend this hotel."

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Mon 26th of September 2005

Not What We Expected

4
Good
by

"My family (2 adults and 2 children ages 10 and 12) stayed at the Comodora Playa Hotel For 11 nights in July 2005. We found the hotel to be for more senior people rather than family's and couples.
We have been on numerous "All Inclusive" holidays and this one was probably the worst for a number of reasons. The "All Inclusive" was more like half bored (set times) and nothing to eat after dinner (which was not good for the children). No pool bar which meant if the kids wanted ice cream they would have to take their swimming gear off and get dressed to go into the dining room to get it, same for drinks, no eating was allowed out of the dining room at any time not even snacks. The entertainment was non existent within this hotel and absolutely nothing for the children to do. The pool area was shaded by large trees and very small, it was extremely noisy due to the location. The hotel is situated on a corner site on a busy road which is accessible for palma nova and magaluf. Magaluf comes alive at night and stays that way till about 6am so it is very noicy when you are trying to sleep and although this hotel is in Palma Nova, it is actually on the edge of both resorts. The food was ok but alot of it was the same each evening, the children struggled to find food they liked because they would have sauces on everything. The hotel itself is super clean and we had a family room which was just brilliant, it was big and it also had a seperate bedroom for the kids so that made our holiday just having that. The views onto the bay from the our room were beautiful but at night it was extremely noisy due to party goers going onto the beach and skinny dipping till 6am. Overall, It was definately not a 4 star hotel and also not for kids. Apparently the bar downstairs was part of the hotel some years ago but has not been bought out seperately so when the bar in the hotel closes at 11.45pm you could go downstairs or outside to other bars but obviously have to pay. We were lucky because we got an extremely good deal on this holiday, we went through Flyglobespam but we heard what other people had paid which was double to us and if that was the case I would have seriously complained. I would got back to Palma Nova but would rather go more into Palma Noval itself and get a better hotel which caters for all ages.

Hope this information helps !"

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Sat 10th of September 2005

a great holiday

5
Brilliant
by

"Myself and my two teenagers enjoyed our stay here for a week in mid October. the beds were comfortable, room clean, shower had good pressure too. We loved the quality and variety of food, new choices every day. The staff were really helpful and friendly too. Loved it! felt right at home. They had some entertainment on which 2 out of 4 was good enough to stay in for. It was great to have a go at belly dancing!
Location was brilliant, right near the beach and not far from the bars of Magaluf and the noise didn't wake us.
downside was that on first night we were transferred to another hotel as they didn't have a room available, but we were back just after breakfast so only delayed twelve hours.
Would definitely return and recommend to others."

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Mon 17th of October 2011

Rating breakdown

  • 5 Beach
  • 5 Room
  • 4 Pool
  • 5 Service
  • 5 Dining
  • 4 Amenities
  • 5 Food

Great hotel but too near Magaluf

4
Good
by

"We are a couple well travelled and with experience in the hotel buisness. This hotel sells itself short. It has new owners who could cut out the downmarket single sex three day loss leaders by upgrading the bedrooms with very little effort. The beautiful beach views from the rooms sell this hotel with not much effort. We booked one week fully inc and was surprised to find a great atmosphere created by the friendly staff. The food was good and well presented and the dining room pleasant. Its easy to get around the island by bus, and the sightseeing boat is a very enjoyable cruise around the coast. Book if you dont mind hen and stags being noisey at night, who looked out of place in the hotel at daytime"

Holiday details

  • Travel date: Thu 19th of May 2011

Rating breakdown

  • 5 Beach
  • 2 Room
  • 3 Pool
  • 4 Service
  • 4 Dining
  • 4 Amenities
  • 4 Food
Write A Review

Hotels near Hotel Seramar Comodoro Playa

Stayed at Hotel Seramar Comodoro Playa? Share your insight.

Top traveller tips for Hotel Seramar Comodoro Playa

  • booboy66 by booboy66

    "The Godfather Restaurant just outside the Hotel was very good and always busy. "

  • Claire + mum by Claire + mum

    "Hire a car and see the rest of the island. It`s supposed to be beautiful, and not so touristy! "

  • holidayaddict by holidayaddict

    "stroll along the prom to the second bay and enjoy the fishing from the rocks "

Hotel Seramar Comodoro Playa is also called

  • Hotel Comodoro
  • Comodoro Hotel Palma Nova
  • Comodoro Palma Nova

Similar hotels around Hotel Seramar Comodoro Playa