Elmbank Hotel
, YorkElmbank Hotel reviews
- Holiday Date:Apr 2011
- Advice: Rest, relax and just enjoy your visit
- Good For: City Breaks
- Board Basis:Breakfast Included
- Tour Operator:Booked Independently
Was this review helpful? Yes
when we arrived at the hotel i nearly died!!!!the windows were dirty and the net curtins were black!!there were weeds where flowers should have been and the grass was overgrown!!!!
After finally plucking courage to enter the building,we were given our room.it was basic but fairly clean,all linen was clean!!!
the breakfast was good and the waiter was brill,nothing was too much trouble for him!!!!overall the staff (apart from 1 receptionist)were polite.
The hotel was about a 20 minute stroll from the center,all downhill,a taxi back was around £4.50ish.
My advice to the hotel owners would be give the hotel some tlc....first impressions do count!!
- Holiday Date:May 2010
- Advice: dont look at the dirty nets!
- Good For: City Breaks
- Board Basis:Breakfast Included
- Tour Operator:Booked Independently
Was this review helpful? Yes
A family crowd to celebrate an aged relative's eightieth. One of us spent several hours on the net finding this gem.
The Elmbank is a art nouveau gem - or at least the hallway is - and it lulls you in a torpor of expectation... You know how you think it's a great change from modern hotels which are bland, soulless and staffed by morons. Well, at least their rooms mean you can swing a cat have seen a decorator since Adolf Hitler gave up his day job.
Many of the things previous Elmbank reviewers have mentioned struck a chord. Some of the staff were just unpleasant or vacant. Checking in was arduous and they tell you to pay up in advance. The hotel was labyrinthine and peppered with notices that are laughably rude, ungrammatical and/or uncommunicative.
Our room was a medium to large cupboard with a staircase just inside the door. The joint was noisy - a wedding downstairs thankfully ended around midnight. But we were awakened by a corridor stomping crowd at 2AM the second night. The kitchens start tossing saucpans around at about five and both nights there was a strange electrical whine/hum for 20-30 minutes every hour or so that wakes you up again when it finally stops - just like you've suddenly gone stone deaf!
Never again.
PS Breakfast is a shambles - and don't eat the sausages, they cook them for less than a minute each!
- Holiday Date:May 2009
- Advice: York is wonderful. Spend at least a week there (but not at the Elmbank!)
- Activities: Try the Olive Tree by Clifford Tower
- Good For: City Breaks
- Board Basis:Bed & Breakfast
- Tour Operator:Booked Independently
Was this review helpful? Yes
A beautiful lobby but the rooms were in need of work.
The staff were rude and unable to deal with the general public with the exception of the night porter.
To get service in the bar was difficult as according to the staff they had no bar man and it was up to the guest to wander around the hotel looking for someone to serve them.
Once you found somebody they made out they were doing you a favour to serve you.
I and many other guests just went out to get a drink and something to eat.
As a person who works in a hotel and has done for the last 10 years, I feel it is a disgrace to the trade.
- Board Basis:Bed & Breakfast
- Tour Operator:Accommodation2u
Was this review helpful? Yes
Awful.
The Hotel looks nice from the outside but we ended up in "The Lodge" next door. The room was big but smelled musty and the decor was Chintzy.
We had not hot water for the evening shower. I called reception and she told us "I had a shower before and it was fine" (how nice for her!). Didn't help us though.
Our friends stayed in the room next door. We found out (the next morning) that the door to their room wouldn't lock properly so it wasn't secured the evening we were out.
Rude staff, smelly, inadequate hot water systems, unsecured rooms. It's no wonder they make you pay on arrival. Even Basil Faulty would be disgusted with this hotel.
But seriously, I urge you to look elsewhere.
- Board Basis:Bed & Breakfast
- Tour Operator:Laterooms.com
Was this review helpful? Yes
I booked this hotel after reading a number of reviews which seemed to imply that the place was average to good.
I'm not sure what the Hotel itself is like as we ended up in the Lodge which is just over the road. For £85 a night the room was tiny, you could only just walk around the bed, the decor was awful, flowery bed covers and holly green blankets and pink walls. It had the smallest TV you could get with no remote and although the bathroom was acceptable there was no hot water for a shower on the first night and we were advised we would have to wait as others must be using it.
The location of the hotel is good as it is in walking distance to the town but the front door of the lodge bangs every time someone closes it. I would not recommend this hotel to a friend, it certainly was not 3* and I will not be visiting it again in case I happen to have to stay in the lodge.
- Board Basis:Room Only
- Tour Operator:Booked Independently
Was this review helpful? Yes
- Click here for best prices on Elmbank Hotel, York
-
Elmbank Hotel: Book Now - Pay Later!
Venere.comBest Prices & No Cancellation Fees! Hotels, Apartments, B&Bs and More! -
Elmbank Hotel: Save up to 50% off Hotels Everyday
Expedia.comPhotos, Reviews and the Guaranteed Lowest Prices -
York: Save money, Book now !
Booking.comExcellent choice, Low rates -
York: Book now for big savings!
hotels.comOutstanding choice of hotels all over the world at fantastic prices. - Sponsored links
Traveller Ratings
Write a review- Bar/lounge
- Restaurant
- Room Service
- Wheelchair Access
- Click here for best prices on Elmbank Hotel, York
-
Elmbank Hotel: Save money, Book now !
Booking.comExcellent choice, Low rates -
Elmbank Hotel: Book online.
Hotels.comSee maps & reviews for over 140,000 Hotels worldwide! -
Elmbank Hotel: Discount Hotel Rooms
Priceline.comMore Ways to Save on Hotels. Save up to 50% on Top Brands. -
Elmbank Hotel: Save on Hotel + Flight Packages
Expedia VacationsBook with Best Price Guarantee. Click or call now: 1 - 800-713-8214 - Sponsored links
View Map of Elmbank Hotel
Hotels Near Elmbank Hotel
-
Your Hotel Newington
Your Hotel Newington0.1Check Availability
-
Mount Royale Hotel
Mount Royale Hotel0.1Check Availability
- Carlton House 0.1
- The Ashberry B&B 0.2
-
Acer Guest House
Acer Guest House0.2Check Availability
Do you own Elmbank Hotel?
- Promote your business with Holiday Watchdog content
- To respond to a review, use the Management Response Form




After reading previous reviews I must admit that I did not know what to expect but I need not have feared, for the Elmbank Hotel, York was a joy to stay at.
The staff were extremely welcoming and friendly and they offered a first class service. Nothing was a trouble and they made my overnight stay with them an enjoyable experience.
The decor was beautiful and the atmosphere was a relaxing, inviting one. The room was small but sufficient with extremely comfortable clean beds and a newly refurbished, exceptionally clean bathroom.
I would not hesitate to return to this fine hotel and I look forward to the next opportunity of staying there again. Special thanks to the reception staff, Olga, the attentive staff in the breakfast room and Pauline, the Head of Housekeeping. All were wonderful and provided perfect, friendly customer service which added to my enjoyable stay. Thank you all ever so much.