Carter Hotel

, New York City
1 star Map this hotel
hotel photo More hotel photos
gulvet af noget der vist var garderobeskab indgangsdør til værelse misligeholdt installation
Find great package holiday deals in New York City

Carter Hotel reviews

Sort by Date | Rating
Unsafe Do Not Stay Here
1 / 10
Aug 2011, Kaye

This hotel is certainly a destination for "budget" holidays and so it was not surprising that it was shabby and dirty - my 3 friends and I (all girls aged ~23) had prepared for this eventuality given that we were touring America for a long period of time. What was... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

Giving this hotel a 1 is generous....
1 / 10
Sep 2007, Miss F Todd

Giving this hotel a 1 is generous. The rooms are filthy; our room was not cleaned once during our stay. We were provided two small towels (I would use them as hand towels at home as they were so small), for a 5 night stay two towels for two adults is not enough, especially... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

Never stay at this hotel. Although it...
1 / 10
Jan 2007, Miss LA Gelling

Never stay at this hotel. Although it is centrally located in Times Square and the prices seem reasonable, it is the most disgusting place I have ever seen. I wish I had have read reviews before we booked it. On arrival at the Carter the first thing we noticed was the tacky... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

The Hotel Carter is located on west...
7 / 10
Jun 2006, Ajita

The Hotel Carter is located on west 43rd Street, just of Times Square. The best thing that can be said of this hotel is its location and price. At $100 a night, this is one of the few cheap hotels in New York City that also includes an en suite bathroom. The hotel itself... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

If you have any sense, DO NOT USE...
1 / 10
Dec 2005, Mrs J Fuller

If you have any sense, DO NOT USE THIS TOUR OPERATOR, they left my sister and her boyfriend high and dry in NYC as they over booked the CARTER hotel by many bookings. They were not alone.... the rooms were dirty and basic is not the word...disgusting...the emergency phone... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

First of all the staff are nasty,...
1 / 10
Nov 2005, Mr MSL 

First of all the staff are nasty, rude, people, not too much English. The whole place smells like fried cabbage, the room was about 10X10, carpet for a head board, people had wrote their names on the wall in are room, nasty dirty carpet that was pieced together out of... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

There are basic hotels, and then -...
1 / 10
Oct 2005, Mr MM Mayskiy

There are basic hotels, and then - there is Carter; this is a separate category. The filthy, dirty, smelly hotel is governed by uniquely rude and incompetent staff. Our reservations were ignored, and despite the fact that we called to confirm the reservation and to let the... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

Unfortunately minus ratings are not...
1 / 10
Feb 2005, Mr M D'amore

Unfortunately minus ratings are not available. I booked this hotel due to its price & location, A budget Hotel for a budget traveller ... no problem I thought "It couldn’t be that bad" From the start I knew I had made an error, the staff were rude getting my back up... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

We arrived at the Hotel to be greeted...
1 / 10
Dec 2004, Mrs S Johnson

We arrived at the Hotel to be greeted by 6 Chinese people sat on the floor in reception eating food. It turned out that these people were the family of the owner, we arrived at the check in desk and gave our paperwork to a much stressed young man. He asked the Chinese... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

Do not stay there!!!!! It is filthy...
1 / 10
Dec 2004, D Dean

Do not stay there!!!!! It is filthy from the moment you walk in, in the elevator, down the hallway, and worst of all the room itself.....The hotel staff at check in is very accommodating however they have nothing better to offer than a dirty room... This hotel should... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

Read 1,128 additional reviews of Carter Hotel
Stayed at Carter Hotel? Share your insight. Write A Review Add Photos

More Traveller reviews of Carter Hotel

Can you say HAUNTED? from A TripAdvisor Member
I would like to start off by saying that the lady at the front desk was RUDE! The bell guy was nice as well as the cleaning girl. We started out at a nicer hotel but wanted to save some money so we would have more money to spend eating and shopping. When I first enterded our room I felt a little creeped out - I decided it was because the hotel was an old one and and left it at that. Now I am not one who is scared by much - but I could not sleep any of the 4 nights we were there. When I did fall asleep I was woke up by .. umm.. something in... more
Run away -- FAST! from A TripAdvisor Member
We stayed here in Nov. 2002 and it was awful! We were on the 17th floor and only one of the three elevators worked only part of the time. Our headboards on the bed were made out of carpet and the tile in the bathroom was held up with scotch tape. The grill in the door let us hear everyone talking in the hallway all night long! Thank God it was only for one night -- that was more than enough!
was good from A TripAdvisor Member
if you don't expect the hilton, carter is a fine, cheap and clean place to stay. The rooms are cleand evry day and the owners are friedly. Staying in the carter is the best solution to be in the center of the big apple for not too much money
Don't be put off by the reviews - The Carter is habitable! from A TripAdvisor Member
I was on my way to NYC on very short notice, which left me with practically just two options regarding accomodation: either pay 300 $ at a **** hotel or then 89$ at The Carter. I read the reviews on this page and decided to try The Carter despite the horrendous opinions. My brave decision was mainly due to the fact that the few Europeans that had posted a review found the hotel acceptable - as far as Americans are concerned, nothing is ever good enough for the (No offence, though!)Well, arriving at the hotel I thought I would practically... more
Dump from A TripAdvisor Member
The Hotel Carter is a total dump. This is where welfare people vacation in NY. Dont even think of staying there. THe mattresses look like hammocks they are so old and there is literally 2 inches of dust under the beds. The TV was so old it had only 13 channels. The AC was broken. The bellman wanted $20 to get us in all the citys cool clubs even though we didnt ask. Of course he was lying in the first place. Total dump. New York has a lot of these dump hotels. To bad as they really need the visitors right now but they hotels are... more
No-tell Motel from A TripAdvisor Member
The on-line pictures of the rooms are inaccurate at best! The minute you walk in the door the experience heads down hill. Nasty lobby, rude desk clerk, antiquated elevators - enter at your own risk!! Stay at the risk of your mental health and physical well-being! The rooms smelled of urine. Door knobs were missing on the bathrooms. The bathroom looked like it had never been cleaned. The tile was covered in mold. The handle fell off the shower faucet. The window would not shut, so the room was extremely cold. There were no controls for heat... more
Disgracefull from A TripAdvisor Member
This hotel is disgrace full, nasty , the staff does not speak english, are we not in the United States. Nasty, Nasty, you know that it is bad whn the NYPD tell you to get out of the hotel for your safty. What ever you do , spend the extra money, do not stay in this dump.
looks bad from the hilton from A TripAdvisor Member
Looking from the Hilton @ 42nd street, I am glad I paid the extra $100 a night for my stay. With the lites burnt out at night it says Carter HTE which I believe may stand for Carter Hell Tonight Everlasting. Good Luck.
Yikes! from A TripAdvisor Member
I have stayed at this hotel in the past, but it is not very nice. It is in a prime New York area for tourists, but is very run down. My biggest memory was of all of the roaches in the bathrooms that come up through the pipes at night! Don't expect the Hilton.
I agree with the others who stayed here!!! from A TripAdvisor Member
My husband and I originally booked at the Habitat Hotel, online, about a week before we were scheduled to be in the city. We did not get our room at Habitat, because a pipe broke, and were, instead, offered an "upgrade" to the Hotel Carter. As soon as we got into the lobby, I knew that we were in for something to be remembered! First of all, the original rates for the Habitat Hotel were supposed to be honored. The person behind the desk was rude, and insisted that they had no rooms for the price we were to pay at the original hotel. It... more
Click here for best prices on Carter Hotel, New York City
Hotel Carter: Book Now - Pay Later!
Best Prices & No Cancellation Fees! Hotels, Apartments, B&Bs and More! Venere.com
New York City: Save on hotel + air
Get the lowest price on your vacation with our Best Price Guarantee Expedia Vacations
New York City: Save money, Book now !
Excellent choice, Low rates Booking.com
New York City: Book now for big savings!
Outstanding choice of hotels all over the world at fantastic prices. hotels.com

Carter Hotel also called

  • carter hotel new york
  • carter hotel nyc
  • hotel carter
  • hotel carter new york
  • hotel carter new york city
  • Address: 250 West 43rd Street 10036, New York City, New York

Traveller Ratings

Write a review
Overall
3.5 / 10
1,150 reviews
Brilliant
22
Good
98
Average
213
Poor
169
Awful
648
Room
3.5/10
Service
4/10
Value
5.5/10
Cleanliness
3.5/10
Location
9/10
Hotel AmenitiesHotel Description
Rooms: 700 See Amenities
Click here for best prices on Carter Hotel, New York City
Hotel Carter: Save up to 50% off Hotels Everyday
Photos, Reviews and the Guaranteed Lowest Prices Expedia.com
Hotel Carter: Book online.
See maps & reviews for over 140,000 Hotels worldwide! Hotels.com
Hotel Carter: Breakfast included
Best price - No reservation costs Olotels.com
Hotel Carter: Save on Hotel + Flight Packages
Book with Best Price Guarantee. Click or call now: 1 - 800-713-8214 Expedia Vacations
Share your opinion with other travellers. Write a review.

View Map of Carter Hotel

Map for Carter Hotel

Hotels Near Carter Hotel

distance(miles) rating
Looking for a beach holiday? Get ideas here

Explore New York City

New York City Photos New York City Holidays New York Hotels New York City Forum
Nearby Airports
New York La Guardia (LGA) 6.1 miles Newark Liberty International (EWR) 10.5 miles New York John F Kennedy International (JFK) 13.8 miles
Popular Holiday Destinations
Almeria City Holidays Coimbra Holidays Gumbet Holidays Marmaris Holidays Maspalomas Holidays
Other Featured Hotels
Barcelo Fuerteventura Thalasso Spa
Caleta De Fuste
Bellevue Lagomonte
Puerto Alcudia
Canifor Hotel
Qawra
Club Calimera Thalassa Village
Skanes
Dubrovnik Palace Hotel
Dubrovnik
Esplendido Hotel
Puerto Soller
Fiesta Club Palm Beach
Playa d'en Bossa
Grecian Park Hotel
Protaras
Hotel Baia Lara
Antalya
Hotel Cap Salou
Salou

Do you own Carter Hotel?