Amsterdam Court Hotel

, New York City
3 star Map this hotel
hotel photo More hotel photos
chipped, stained furniture view from room TV and
Find great package holiday deals in New York City

Amsterdam Court Hotel reviews

Sort by Date | Rating
5 / 10
Jan 2009, jacobvats

The Amsterdam Court is a find for those who prefer a smaller, more personal hotel, with an unbeatable location near Broadway. The lobby is compact and welcoming, and guests have their own private lounge stocked with books and newspapers. Location:This hotel is located in... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

1 / 10
Jun 2008, Miss CA Aguenier

Beware of this hotel. They absolutely refused to give me back the prints of my credit card, a credit card that I only used for this hotel. They were even ignoring my questions regarding its safe keeping. I used another one for the shopping. I recently got debited 2,000€... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

8 / 10
Jan 2008, Miss K Carter

This hotel was in a prime location for Broadway, 5th Avenue & Central Park. The staff were friendly offering safety a deposit box for free and to book us a car back to the airport. The car service was booked and we were given an exact price for the trip. The hotel room had... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

6 / 10
Jan 2008, Mrs L J O'Neill

We stayed in the Amsterdam Court for five nights over the New Year. Our room was very clean if small, but the location more than made up for this. The staff were very friendly and knowledgeable even if most of them were eastern European. Ask for the hotel shuttle bus to and... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

3 / 10
Mar 2006, Miss C Collins

This hotel was clean and basic. The rooms were comfortable, however depending where your room is we found the noise quite bad. Now I did expect New York to be a noisy city with sirens and traffic all night but there is an all night car park next to this hotel and our... more

Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

Read 478 additional reviews of Amsterdam Court Hotel
Stayed at Amsterdam Court Hotel? Share your insight. Write A Review Add Photos

More Traveller reviews of Amsterdam Court Hotel

Stay somewhere else
First of all great location and that's it. Went to New York with my brother and was given a queens size bed even though we had booked two singles. They did give us a roll away though WOW!. The Hotel is very easy to miss and when we arrived at reception the staff were very abrupt as if to say "This is what you've you've got and your three thousand miles away from home so what you going to do about it" The room was lighted by a what must have been a 15 watt light and you needed a torch to find your personal effects. The toilet was cramped and... more
Absolutely vile!!!
As our first choice was being renovated,we took this one instead.BIG MISTAKE! Absolutely vile!The pics made it look good,boutiquey even,but,boy,are you ever in for a disappointment.The gloomiest rooms we have ever stayed in.Room327 was where we laid our heads in March 2004.No daylight at all,tired decor too,didn't help either.It was prison-like in fact.Horrible corridors,dreadful halls(creepy almost)I could go on...And as for the staff,only the young doorman warrants a favourable mention,the rest were surly,unhelpful and unpleasant to anyone... more
Great Location - really nice
We booked the Carter hotel originally - but after reading the terrible reviews on here we changed and upgraded to the Amsterdam Court - and I'm glad we did. It was great - the location is amazing - you step out of the hotel and just down the street is Times Square. And yet the room was really quiet in the nights. The air conditioning unit in the window was a little noisy - but not that bad. The room was just as published in the brouchure - really modern mix of browns - really smart. We did experience problems checking in - they did not... more
Small but well formed
We booked this hotel partly because it was cheap on expedia and because the reviews on this very site told us what we wanted to know! We stayed 3 nights in summary, POSTIVE 1) It was clean and comfortable 2) Breakfast was plentful 3) There was a bar attached 4) It was a great location close to subway and time sq 5) Staff we friendly and polite 6) Price NEGATIVE 1) rooms we stayed in (ground floor) had 4 doors all within 6ft, this lead to a resonable amount of noise from other guests 2) No natural light in the room at all 3) Breakfast was... more
What's with all the negative reviews? It's a Great Hotel!
OK, prior to my trip I had carefully researched good places to stay at so I can make the most of my stay. So upon finding this hotel thru an online booking site- I wanted to see what people thought of it. I read all the reviews and some made me worry about this hotel- that I literally had nightmares days before my trip! So, I took a leap of faith and just booked it. I figure I only need a place to sleep in the Big Apple! so here are the positives that i think will prove the other reviews wrong! PROS LOCATION: Great Location! steps... more
Dark and depressing in the bright lights of the big city!
I just want to say that I was expecting a tourist class hotel along the lines of a Days Inn or Holiday Inn but although the room was clean (and you can't fault the location) this was a depressing hotel, the worse I have ever stayed in. My advice would be to book the Days Inn around the corner (at least you know what to expect from a chain) but if it is too late then ask for a room at the front overlooking the street such as 310 (we moved to this room as the water pipes and the air conditioning unit were too noisy in the first room...... more
Great Location and Friendly Staff!
After reading all the various reviews here we were unsure as to what we would be turning up to last weekend. When we got there we were more than pleasantly surprised. We had none of the problems described below and yes other than the lack of natural daylight in the room this was an excellent value for money place to stay. The location is fabulous and only minutes walk from Times Square. Very close to 50th Street subway and close to a number of great places to eat. We especially enjoyed the late night cocktail lounge!! Friendly staff,... more
Great location!
This was my first time in NYC. Stayed there Aug 17 to Aug 22. Via the internet, I got a great price on the room $135 for each nite. The room, as others have said, was very small, but it was clean. The bathroom was pretty and clean, but the water temperature does fluctuate quite a bit. However, the location of this hotel is fantastic. It's close to two subway stations, in the midst of restaurants and stores that are open 24 hours, right by Broadway and a few blocks from Times Square. It was well worth the money and the small room... more
no frills-great location
The best thing about the place is it's ideal location near all theaters, restaurant row, etc. The rooms are quite small-(although VERY clean) and the lobby and hallways are dark and dingy. The breakfast was held each morning in a small hallway-like area which was very crowded. The hallways and public areas were un-air-conditioned and the elevator was....quirky-with no visible inspection certificate either. I used the stairs. Hot water was intermittent and the pipes rattled noisily on those rare occasions when you could get the shower... more
Not too bad for our budget
After reading the reviews we were quite prepared for the worse. It wasn't that bad after all. We stayed here from Aug 1st - Aug 5th. The hot water in the shower worked, the little mini air-con worked too. The staff were a bit strict adhearing to their policies but still polite. Coming prepared with the knowledge the the rooms were small, made it more easy to settle in even though there were 4 of us (2 kids and 2 adults). We were ready to comprimise space for location and save us extra to do some shopping. Most other hotels in the area cost... more

Amsterdam Court Hotel also called

  • amsterdam court
  • amsterdam court hotel new york
  • amsterdam court new york
  • amsterdam hotel new york
  • hotel amsterdam court
  • Address: 226 West 50th Street 10019, New York City, New York

Traveller Ratings

Write a review
Overall
6 / 10
500 reviews
Brilliant
63
Good
172
Average
98
Poor
73
Awful
94
Room
5.5/10
Service
7/10
Value
7/10
Cleanliness
7/10
Location
9.5/10
Hotel AmenitiesHotel Description
  • Bar/lounge
  • Restaurant
  • Wheelchair Access
Rooms: 119 More Amenities
Share your opinion with other travellers. Write a review.

View Map of Amsterdam Court Hotel

Map for Amsterdam Court Hotel

Hotels Near Amsterdam Court Hotel

distance(miles) rating
Looking for a beach holiday? Get ideas here

Explore New York City

New York City Photos New York City Holidays New York Hotels New York City Forum
New York La Guardia (LGA) 5.8 miles Newark Liberty International (EWR) 10.8 miles New York John F Kennedy International (JFK) 13.8 miles