Pennsylvania Hotel

, New York City
2 star Map this hotel
hotel photo More hotel photos
The room Douche Toilette
Find great package holiday deals in New York City
Back to Pennsylvania Hotel

Pennsylvania Hotel reviews

Sort by Date | Rating
« 1 2
The hotel was always busy, always...
2 / 10
May 2006, pattiluce

The hotel was always busy, always people coming and going. Its a case of faded splendour.
We were given a room, so tiny and scruffy that we had to ask for an upgrade, however there were none available and one of the lovely reception ladies...Sheila, told us that we would be wasting our money. She was lovely and gave us about 4 rooms to look at. We chose the best one, but by this time we were so tired we didn’t really care. The bed sheets were changed every day and clean towels also.
No tea/coffee making facilities though, as were advertised and the free breakfast never materialized. This hotel is very close to Maceys, and is also ideal for grabbing a quick bite to eat, you don’t have to walk far. The two restaurants adjoining the hotel are very nice.
All in all if you don’t spend much time in your room, this hotel is ideal, scruffy, but lashings of hot water and like I said clean towels and sheets every day.
Not at all as their website depicts it. False advertising.

  • Board Basis:Select
  • Tour Operator:Octopus Travel
Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

This hotel should be condemned!! We...
1 / 10
Dec 2005, Mrs J Poll

This hotel should be condemned!! We checked in at 9 p.m. and got to our room where we found a cracked shower, dirty bathroom, filthy room, and paint peeling off the walls. We complained and were told that you couldn't expect more! They gave us a key to another room and it was worse!! Don't stay there!!
We ended up walking the streets to look for another hotel which thankfully we found and moved there at midnight!! That hotel was called the Affinia which was just about one block away and was ten times better for not much more money at all.

  • Board Basis:Room Only
  • Tour Operator:Lastminute
Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

On arrival we was allocated room 1512...
1 / 10
Nov 2005, Ms Y Walton

On arrival we was allocated room 1512 on 15th floor, we exited the lift to a disgusting stale smell, walking down corridor every door was damaged and stained, we feared the worst for the condition of the room, but nothing could have prepared us for the state of it, we went straight back down to reception where we was reallocated to room 218 on the 2nd floor, yet again on our exit from the lift there was still this awful smell and all the doors was damaged as on the 15th floor. On entering our second allocated room we soon realized that although this was slightly better than the first but as you will see from our photographs did certainly not match the description as described on your website! Torn bed sheets stained walls and disgusting chair not too mention no hairdryer or clock radio as described. we went back to reception, again I expressed my feeling in the condition of the second room but they had no other rooms available and was told that we would be moved the next day, I rang reception the next morning, whilst on hold I listened to a recorded message adverting the hotel as RECENTLY REFURBISHED, I was told we would be reallocated a third room at 4pm.
We was allocated a third room 512a on 5th floor, by this time we still hadn’t unpacked our bags, on exiting the lift on this occasion we did notice that the smell wasn’t half as bad and that doors in corridor looked slightly better, the room was 100% better than the first room and 80% better than the second room, but with the telephone had been ripped out of the wall, bath was a disgrace and wardrobe doors hanging off.... I have photographs to prove it, yet Click4hotel dismissed my complaint as in their terms and conditions it states that some of the rooms are tired in my opinion they were more comatose!! please take my advise Think twice about booking this hotel or using Click4hotel.

  • Board Basis:Room Only
  • Tour Operator:Click4hotel
Show Prices

Was this review helpful? Yes

« 1 2
Read 2,720 additional reviews of Pennsylvania Hotel
Stayed at Pennsylvania Hotel? Share your insight. Write A Review Add Photos

Traveller Ratings

Write a review
Overall
4.5 / 10
2,754 reviews
Brilliant
102
Good
374
Average
648
Poor
465
Awful
1163
Room
4.5/10
Service
5/10
Value
5.5/10
Cleanliness
5/10
Location
9/10
Hotel AmenitiesHotel Description
  • Bar/lounge
  • Fitness Centre
  • Restaurant
  • Suites
  • Wheelchair Access
Rooms: 1705 More Amenities
Share your opinion with other travellers. Write a review.

View Map of Pennsylvania Hotel

Map for Pennsylvania Hotel

Hotels Near Pennsylvania Hotel

Looking for a beach holiday? Get ideas here

Explore New York City

New York City Photos New York City Holidays New York Hotels New York City Forum
New York La Guardia (LGA) 6.4 miles Newark Liberty International (EWR) 10.2 miles New York John F Kennedy International (JFK) 13.6 miles